Yusuf Ali documents that the Koran is a book of myths, fables and fairy tales.
Pre-Islamic Sources for material in the Quran

Click to View

Islam: Truth or Myth? start page

 

 

Yusuf Ali documents that the Koran is a book of myths, fables and fairy tales.
Yusuf Ali is a Muslim scholar who translated the Quran.

"Many scholars are agreed that the stories found in the Qur'an were derived from the legends and myths of Arabs, Jews, Persians, and Christians. In other words, they did not come from heaven but from earth. Their source is not Allah but human story tellers. This is why many scholars view the Qur'an as a fanciful book of ancient tales. This will not come as a surprise to anyone who actually reads the Qur'an. It is primarily composed of old fables and myths which convolute the names, dates, events, and places of biblical and secular history into incoherent fantasies. Such fantastic stories as the youths in the cave, the she camel, the monkey people and the night journey are only faint garbled reflections of the original tales.

Example: Yusuf Ali's translation and commentary on the Qur'an is well known and accepted all over the world:

  1. In his comments on the text, he traces the stories of the Qur'an back to the original Arab, Jewish, Persian or Christian legends from which they were derived.
  2. He does not deny the earthly sources of the Qur'an. Instead, he documents them!

If the Qur'an is a confused and jumbled record of ancient "stories" drawn from the various nations conquered by the Arabs, this becomes the most serious threat to Islam's claim of divine revelation. Maududi was right. Once we identify the sources of the Qur'an, it is no longer a revelation."

Surah

verse

Source of story according to the footnotes and comments in Yusuf Ali's Translation and Commentary of the Koran.

2

60

Jewish And Arab legends

 

65

Jewish legends

 

125

Arab legends

 

158

Arab legends

 

189

Arab legends

 

194

Arab legends

 

196

Arab legends

 

197

Arab legends

 

198

Arab legends

 

200

Arab legends

 

259

Jewish legend

3

49

Christian legend

7

65

Arab legends

 

73

Arab legends

 

85

Arab legends

11

59

Arab legends

18

9

Christian legend

 

110

Persian source

74

32

Arab legends

 

By Dr. Robert Morley

Click to View

 

Go To Start: WWW.BIBLE.CA